Hicksville Diner Hicksville
Hicksville Diner Logo

Hicksville Diner

@

4.5920 reviews

Hicksville Diner is a cozy eatery nestled at 495 E Old Country Rd, Hicksville, NY. Family-owned, it embodies classic diner charm, merging quality food with welcoming service.

Since returning in 2019, Hicksville Diner has rekindled its legacy from the early 2000s when it was renowned for having some of the best diner cuisine on Long Island. The atmosphere feels homey, perfect for a hearty meal anytime.

This diner offers a mix of traditional American dishes, from breakfast favorites to mouthwatering dinners. With a varied menu, it appeals to families, tourists, and locals alike. The experience transcends food—it's about connecting with the community.

About

The story of Hicksville Diner starts with a devoted family, where a father and four brothers built a culinary reputation in the early 2000s. Their winning charm was recognized when they earned the title of Best Diner on Long Island.

In 2019, the diner reopened to serve the Hicksville area once more. The friendly staff, passionate about quality service, creates an inviting atmosphere for diners. Each visit feels like being welcomed home by family.

Situated conveniently off the highway, Hicksville Diner has become a loveable hub for the community. Families often gather here, creating memories over shared meals. It's a place where everyone feels like part of the family.

Get in Touch

495 E Old Country Rd, Hicksville, NY 11801, United States

Opening Hours

  • Monday 07:00-21:30
  • Tuesday 07:00-21:30
  • Wednesday 07:00-21:30
  • Thursday 07:00-21:30
  • Friday 07:00-21:30
  • Saturday 07:00-21:30
  • Sunday 07:00-21:30

Where to Visit

Get Directions

Customer Reviews

"Kind and friendly staff. Paninis were HUGE! We all took food home. Loved the Greco panini - sweet potato fries rocked. Would go here again!"

- Amanda H.

"Very nice little restaurant. Everyone was nice. Met my friend and the staff was very helpful. The food was really good and the price was perfect. I never been here before today but it's 5 minutes from my house so I will definitely be coming back more often!"

- Yugvf M.

"Great experience, food was amazing, large portion's, clean , good service"

- Philip D.

"Absolutely love coming here! Ambiance is awesome. Staff is great! Food has been delicious every time! I always ask for my omelette just a little different, and it comes out amazing every time! Conveniently located off the highway and it's a great meeting spot to meet with friends or co-workers. I've had breakfast every time because their eggs have always been cooked to perfection! Maybe next time I'll try lunch. Make a point to stop!"

- BusyB

"We live close by and love taking our friends and family there to give them a taste of a legit American diner. The food is usually yummy, and the servings are huge. The staff knows what they're doing, and they do it well. However, my kid ordered an M&M cookie, and it was kinda stale, and the coffee wasn't the best either. But hey, if you're in the area, give this spot a go. It's worth checking out."

- Henrique F.

"We stopped in for an early dinner on a Sunday afternoon. There was zero wait and only a few customers were seated at the time. The waiter was very nice and helped us with everything we needed. My wife was very happy with her omelet while I had the honey dipped chicken with slaw, green beans, a Cesar salad and a cup of chicken noodle which reminded me of soup at my grandmother's as a child. The green beans were steamed for those interested and the salad was fresh and delicious that was med-heavy on the dressing, not a bad thing but I would suggest dressing on the side for more particular eaters. The chicken was very good, no sauce needed. Crispy and tasty with all different chicken parts included, the way one would expect fried chicken. My wife had a slice of the mudslide cake for desert and enjoyed every bite. Overall I am very happy with our experience and we would be happy to stop in again the next time we are in the area."

- Corey F.

"Visiting from out of town, I was dying to go to a New York diner. You see those paintings of rainy days outside a diner and I just wanted that vibe. Saw this place close to my hotel and was excited to go. This place was AMAZING!! Service was STELLAR. Food was KILLER. it was everything I wanted and more. Huge portions too. I loved everything about it and I'm sad I won't be able to go back. So if you see this, please go!!! Thank you Hicksville Diner! Love from New Mexico!"

- Katie P.
Write a Review

Why Visit

Visiting Hicksville Diner is a culinary adventure. This beloved diner is known for its extensive menu, offering everything from classic breakfast dishes to hearty dinners.

Plan to stop by for breakfast; the omelettes are a favorite among locals. Try the sweet potato fries with your panini. They add a quirky twist to the classic diner fare.

Lunch hours can be busy, especially on Saturdays. For a quieter experience, visit mid-afternoon during the week. Sunday mornings, however, bring a bustling crowd, so expect a lively atmosphere.

Don't miss out on their desserts, especially the mudslide cake. It’s a rich treat that locals rave about. The ambiance is casual, making it a great spot for gatherings.

Most Liked things

The friendly and kind staff at Hicksville Diner often receive high praise. Their attentive service enhances the dining experience, making it feel personal.

Customers rave about the generous portions. Many diners take home leftovers, especially from the giant paninis that are hard to finish.

Breakfast receives consistent accolades, particularly the perfectly cooked omelettes and golden pancakes. It’s a go-to spot for a satisfying start to the day.

Most Disliked things

While Hicksville Diner excels in many areas, there are occasional complaints regarding dessert quality, like stale cookies or subpar coffee.

Some diners expect a more diverse menu. Though they have many options, a few feel certain specialty items could use improvement. Be sure to ask the server for recommendations, as favorites change.

Additionally, the busiest times can mean longer waits, especially on weekends. However, visiting during off-peak hours can mitigate this issue.

FAQ

What makes Hicksville Diner special?

Hicksville Diner offers a family-friendly atmosphere. The diner is known for its great food and excellent service. It has a long-standing history of winning awards for its quality dining experience.

What are some must-try dishes at Hicksville Diner?

You should try the homemade mozzarella sticks and the smokehouse burger. The pancakes and French toast are also fantastic breakfast options. Don't forget the specialty omelettes; they are popular choices as well.

Is Hicksville Diner accessible for everyone?

Yes, Hicksville Diner is wheelchair accessible. It has accessible seating, restrooms, and parking. Families and guests with mobility concerns can enjoy their meals comfortably.

What is the price range at Hicksville Diner?

Most dishes at Hicksville Diner range from $10 to $30. On average, expect to pay around $21.65 for a meal. It’s affordable for families and friends looking for hearty diner food.

Does Hicksville Diner offer takeout or delivery?

Absolutely! Hicksville Diner provides both takeout and delivery services. It’s a great option for a meal on the go or a cozy dinner at home.